Truth take a look at: Does the Canada Kid Get advantages program in reality lower poverty charges? – Nationwide


OTTAWA – Touting the one-year-old Canada Kid Get advantages (CCB) closing week, Justin Trudeau mentioned the $23-billion-a-year measure has raised 300,000 kids out of poverty.

“The (Canada Kid Get advantages) method extra money for 9 out of 10 Canadian households, and it method 300,000 fewer youngsters dwelling in poverty throughout this nation,” Top Minister Justin Trudeau mentioned

Anti-poverty teams say baby advantages are an impressive instrument to assist lower poverty charges, however have frequently puzzled if the CCB’s have an effect on on baby poverty is as huge as Trudeau says.

READ MORE: Because the Canada Kid Get advantages turns 1, who has in reality benefited?

Spoiler alert: The Canadian Press Baloney Meter is a dispassionate exam of political statements culminating in a rating of accuracy on a scale of “no baloney” to “filled with baloney” (entire method underneath).

This one earns a ranking of “numerous baloney” as a result of whilst there’s a trace of reality within the remark – baby poverty is at the decline, and the CCB would possibly assist – it takes just a little of a jump to glue the CCB by myself to 300,000 fewer kids in poverty.


All over the 2015 election, the Liberals predicted their get advantages would elevate 315,000 kids out of poverty. After coming to workplace, that quantity modified to about 292,000. That may be a couple of 40-per-cent aid in baby poverty charges.

The determine of 292,000 – of which 900 are on First International locations reserves – comes from modelling simplest to be had to officers at Employment and Social Building Canada.

WATCH: Elementary revenue the easiest way to assist households put meals at the desk, file suggests

The calculations used probably the most lately to be had choice of the choice of kids dwelling underneath the low-income cutoff, outlined as any circle of relatives that spends 20 in line with cent extra of its revenue than the typical circle of relatives on meals, refuge and clothes. The 2013 information confirmed 755,000 kids dwelling underneath the cutoff.

READ MORE: Ladies in shelters steadily lacking out on federal baby advantages

To achieve the 292,000 quantity, the style incorporated the estimated results in 2015 and 1/2 of 2016 of the former Conservative executive’s building up to the price of the common baby care get advantages, after which a year-and-a-half of results from the Liberal baby get advantages that noticed its first bills in July 2016. Officers assumed the numbers stayed stable thru 2017.

ESDC has in the past informed The Canadian Press that the child-poverty aid have an effect on of the convenience and of different financial tendencies may well be between 241,000 and 415,000 kids in accordance with the dep.’s estimates.

The precise have an effect on gained’t be recognized till 2019 when Statistics Canada releases reputable baby poverty figures for 2017.

A spokeswoman for Social Building Minister Jean-Yves Duclos mentioned the federal government nonetheless estimates a decline of 292,000 kids in poverty, a discount of roughly 40 in line with cent in 2017 in comparison with 2013.


Charles Lammam, director of fiscal research on the Fraser Institute, mentioned that 2013 was once a up to date prime level for baby poverty below the low-income cutoff. The kid poverty fee in accordance with the cutoff was once 11.1 in line with cent in 2013, and dropped to eight.6 in line with cent in 2015, the newest numbers to be had from Statistics Canada.

The drop within the fee ascribed to the kid get advantages is “just a little deceptive” for the reason that fee was once falling “by means of a substantial quantity” ahead of the convenience got here into impact, Lammam mentioned.

WATCH: Learn how to maximize the Canada Kid Get advantages plan

What the federal government is doing with the 300,000 determine is the use of declines in years ahead of the Liberals took workplace and ahead of they introduced within the new get advantages, mentioned David Macdonald, senior economist with the Canadian Centre for Coverage Possible choices.

READ MORE: Indexing Canada Kid Get advantages to inflation would value additional $five.8B by means of 2026, watchdog says

“The important thing level, I feel, is the adaptation between ‘baby poverty will decline by means of 300,000 kids between 2013 and 2017,’ and ‘the CCB is answerable for a 300,000 baby aid in baby poverty,”‘ he mentioned.

“The ones are two other statements.”

Including some other satan in the main points is how the federal government is measuring “poverty.”

WATCH: Ontario launches elementary revenue experiment to take on poverty

The Liberals determined to make use of the low-income cutoff that mavens say will not be a correct measure of poverty as it makes use of a basket of family items from 1992 to check spending between households. Sid Frankel, an affiliate professor of social paintings from the College of Manitoba, mentioned many researchers consider some other benchmark referred to as the low-income measure higher displays a contemporary view of poverty.

READ MORE: Canada Kid Get advantages must building up with inflation, anti-poverty staff says

The low-income measure attracts the poverty line at 1/2 the median family revenue. Federal officers estimate 213,000 fewer kids can be dwelling in poverty this 12 months than in 2013 the use of the low-income measure.


There’s more likely to be a discount of kids dwelling in poverty on the finish of this 12 months, probably by means of 300,000, however Macdonald mentioned perhaps about one-quarter that quantity, or 75,000, may also be chalked as much as the kid get advantages. That smaller decline isn’t one thing to be brushed aside, nevertheless it isn’t the sweeping trade of 300,000 fewer kids dwelling in poverty – or a 40 in line with cent lower – that Trudeau touted.

“I will provide you with a selected measure of the way a lot baloney it’s: Out of the 40 in line with cent aid (in poverty charges), it’s about 30 in line with cent of that,” mentioned Macdonald, who has blogged many times concerning the executive’s estimates.

That’s “numerous baloney.”

That a lot baloney is why Frankel says the federal government must be extra clear concerning the determine.


The Baloney Meter is a undertaking of The Canadian Press that examines the extent of accuracy in statements made by means of politicians. Each and every declare is researched and assigned a ranking in accordance with the next scale:


Supply hyperlink


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here